Archive Links

Consumer Archive
CU System Archive
Market Archive
Products Archive
Washington Archive

News Now

CU System
Emerging Loss Trends Threaten CUs' Financials--From ACUC
NEW YORK (7/8/13)--Credit unions are becoming more susceptible to emerging-loss exposures that can cause immediate losses or result in third-party claims, litigation and subsequent losses, a CUNA Mutual Group risk management specialist said during an America's Credit Union Conference Discovery Breakout Session Wednesday.
Click to view larger image Credit unions face a two-pronged loss threat--from fraudulent acts committed directly against the institution and through litigation by third parties--Roger Nettie, CUNA Mutual Group senior risk management consultant, said during a Discovery Breakout Session at America's Credit Union Conference in New York Wednesday. (Photo provided by CUNA Mutual Group)
Roger Nettie, CUNA Mutual Group senior risk management consultant, said credit unions face a two-pronged loss threat---from fraudulent acts committed directly against the institution and through litigation by third parties.
The conference, presented by the Credit Union National Association in New York City, ended Wednesday.
Direct losses can result from myriad reasons, including employee dishonesty, illegal funds transfers and electronic crime. Employee dishonesty is universal, but the most commonly victimized organizations are in banking and financial services, according to the 2012 Global Fraud Study conducted by the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners.
The study indicated employee frauds lasted a median of 18 months before detection, with a median loss of $140,000. The study showed more than one-fifth of these caused losses of at least $1 million. "The longer a perpetrator works for an organization, the higher fraud losses tend to be," Nettie said. "CUNA Mutual Group claims records show that over a five-year period, employee dishonesty represented just 13% of fraud claims, but 45% of fraud losses."
Many credit unions believe their employees are all trustworthy and that they have strong enough internal controls to prevent internal theft from occurring. Yet, it still occurs.
"Fraud does not discriminate," Nettie said. "There is no immunity to this exposure based on geography, asset size, employee tenure, or past experience."
Another growing area of direct losses is wire fraud, especially from home equity line of credit accounts, with credit unions reporting more than $25 million in losses from 2007 to 2012. The average reported loss in 2012 was $175,000, with some approaching $1 million. "Credit unions experiencing losses generally had inadequate security for large dollar transfers, enabling crooks to easily defeat callback security measures," Nettie said.
Consequently, CUNA Mutual Group implemented new terms with its funds transfer coverage to encourage additional controls for remote requests and discourage the practice of accepting large-dollar remote requests. Nettie offered recommendations to limit wire fraud, such as spotting fraud red flags and using layered levels of security.
Also, electronic crime continues to cause direct losses through computer malware and money mules who illegally transfer money on behalf of scam operators, typically in another country. Prevention measures such as cookies, device recognition, Internet protocol and challenge/response questions have limited effectiveness. As alternatives, Nettie suggested out-of-band authentication, hardware tokens, digital certificates and biometrics.
Liability losses for credit unions continue to be led by employment practices liability (EPL) claims and subsequent litigation. "EPL losses make up nearly two-thirds of all of CUNA Mutual Group Management and Professional Liability losses, with the most common allegations being wrongful termination, retaliation, and race and gender discrimination," Nettie said. He suggested credit unions have updated policies and procedures reviewed by legal counsel and provide regular staff training.
Nettie also discussed the growing incidence of costly lender liability claims, which generally allege the credit union failed to follow state law requirements in their Notices of Intent to sell repossessed property and Notices of Deficiency letters. "Usually, this is a case of you getting sued by your worst borrower and then having it mushroom into a class action lawsuit," Nettie said. "It's vitally important to have your forms reviewed and approved by legal counsel for each applicable state, and train employees on how to properly complete the forms."
If you missed News Now's and Credit Union Magazine's coverage of the ACUC, use the links below.

News Now LiveWire
.@TheNCUA recieved 2,167 comment letters on #RBC2 proposal, as of this morning.
1 hour ago
.@TheKCUA's CUlead gets close up with co-ops #NewsNow
2 hours ago
.@NYCUAtweets in Albany today/Wed for #StateGAC
2 hours ago
#RBC2: When is final draft on the horizon? See #NewsNow
2 hours ago
About 1 in 5 #CUs offer credit-building loans,@SchenkMike @CUNA vice president of economics and statistics, told @CreditCardsCom
18 hours ago