Archive Links

Consumer Archive
CU System Archive
Market Archive
Products Archive
Washington Archive

News Now

CU System
IMotley FoolI analysis Fin crisis hit banks harder than CUs
NEW YORK (11/28/11)--An analysis of the number of failures by financial institution type conducted by The Motley Fool backs up credit unions' argument that credit unions fared better than commercial banks during the 2008 financial crisis and the sluggish economy since.

The Motley Fool looked at commercial banks insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. (FDIC) and at credit unions insured by the National Credit Union Administration. Its conclusion: "While negatively affected by the crisis, credit unions did not experience the sort of radical departure from their baseline rate that banks did," said the Fool (Nov. 22).

The Motley Fool is a well-known website that offers advice and analysis on money and finances.

It noted that a key narrative of the recent Bank Transfer Day events was "to pit normally sleepy credit unions against the big banking industry. Credit union skeptics are quick to point out the fact that credit unions hardly went unscathed during the 2008 financial crisis, yet credit union advocates argue that their institutions fared better than commercial banks." 

The Fool asked if credit unions' claims were backed by numbers, and concluded they were. In 2008, the rate of commercial bank failures (0.60%) was almost triple that of credit unions (0.23%), said the publication.  In 2010, banks' failure rate increased to 1.86%, nearly  five times the credit union rate of 0.40%.

"While the sluggish economy seems to have also negatively affected credit unions, they experienced nowhere near the surge of failures seen in the commercial banking sector," said the Fool.

The publication noted a similar pattern for "problematic" institutions.
Other Resources

RSS print
News Now LiveWire
The Hill reports House Republicans plan to delay Aug. recess to stay in D.C. until they have enough votes to pass bill on border crisis.
7 hours ago
The FHLBs of Des Moines and Seattle announce they have entered into an exclusivity arrangement regarding potential merger of the 2 entities.
8 hours ago
SunCorp and @AlloyaCorp have announced their intent to merge.
10 hours ago
.@TheNCUA bars former employee of Southwest Communities FCU,Melissa Rosing,from work at any federally insured FI. http://t.co/owtVnPxVZT
10 hours ago
Fryzel added @TheNCUA is fed. governmt, thereby will B criticized, but always tried 2 do what is right. McWatters still 2 B sworn in.2of2
12 hours ago